The Best Steel Toe Shoes In The Market Now (#1 Will Make Your Feet Happy!)

Durability without comfort is akin to a machine that isn’t well-oiled — the former will just eventually wear down sans the much-needed ease. The same can be said to steel toe shoes that come without it.

The shoes might protect you in the long run but will tire your feet and give you utter discomfort, something that everyone veers away from when selecting the most comfortable steel toe shoes.

This article is dedicated to doing just about that. We’ll look into the essentials of a steel toe shoe and explore from there the key considerations you need to keep in mind when you finally choose just the best around.

Our top five choices will then be revealed to make your decision much easier. Later on, we’ll also be unveiling the best among these. Without dilly-dallying, let’s now cover some of the core information about steel toe shoes.

**Below, you'll find more detailed reviews, but you can also click links above to check current prices and read customer's reviews on Amazon.


What Is A Steel Toe Shoe?

Best Steel Toe Shoes

Synonymously called as a safety boot, a steel-capped boot or easily a safety shoe, a steel-toe shoe is a durable pair of footwear that features a protective reinforcement in the toe section.

This protects your foot from falling objects (compression). Meanwhile, the reinforcement is usually combined with a mid-sole plate to safeguard your feet against the potential punctures right underneath.

Components And Uses Of A Steel Toe Shoe

Best Steel Toe Shoes

Perhaps the most defining feature of a steel toe shoe is its protective reinforcement that is traditionally made out of steel. Apart from steel, it can also be made of a composite material like thermoplastic polyurethane and aluminum.

You can mostly use steel toe shoes in the construction industry along with other industrial settings. The use of these shoes is required by the occupational safety and health legislation or under insurance prerequisites.

Moreover, they may require the certification of these shoes along with the display of this certification on them directly.

The indicated markings on these shoes will certify that they passed the national and international standards and have also identified the level of protection from a possible impact, penetration, chemical hazard, and electric shock.

Meanwhile, the steel toe shoes that are used in chemical processing and semiconductor manufacturing may also be put into rating to ward off static electricity while the wearer is being protected from electric shock.

Steel toe shoes can also be used in your day-to-day housework like mowing the lawn or other different chores that would require some heavy lifting. You may also use them on your casual walks or even when you run. Essentially, these shoes are just sneakers with, well, a bonus of a steel toe.

These steel-capped shoes can now be seen in a variety of styles such as clogs and sneakers. On the other hand, some are still decidedly quite formal especially for those supervising engineers who visit sites frequently where this type of shoe is mandatory.

Over the years, some brands of steel toe shoes have gone modern that cater to subcultures like skinhead, punk, and rivethead. Also, some brands that were previously affiliated with the fashion industry have also become diversified to infiltrate the safety footwear market.

Recently, the renowned industrial brands such as Caterpillar, JCB, and Rock Fall have all issued licenses to produce safety shoes.

Key Features Of A Steel Toe Shoe

Best Steel Toe Shoes

A handful of steel toe shoe products has now besieged the market, but there are few yet key features that should be looking for to warrant a legitimate pair of safety shoes.

  • The Steel Toe

The most hallmark feature a pair of steel toe shoes must have is, of course, the inclusion of a steel toe. Apart from its added safety and protection when you’re on a work site, this feature should guard you against foreseeable mishaps that often occur in this kind of working environment that involves welding and sharp tools.

Watch this video if you want to check the difference among steel, aluminum, and composite toe caps.

  • The Rubber Sole

Another feature that must be on your checklist is the presence of a rubber sole. It should help you to prevent slipping and is also a provision for a better traction. Rubber-soled steel toe shoes should also safeguard you from getting shocked electrically that is possible when you’re employed on a job site.

  • The Arch And Insoles

An arch and an accompanying set of insoles right in your steel toe shoes are necessary to keep your feet in comfort. They are especially needed as you’d be using your feet for an extended period.

Now, if you’re the type who’d like to modify the level of comfort and support your feet are richly deserving, you may simply go for insoles that can be taken out, allowing you ultimately to make an adjustment.

  • The Fit

Each steel toe shoe is designed to fit the user’s set of feet. With that being said, your safety shoes are specially developed to cater to everyone’s sizing. But when it finally comes to choosing them, it’s strongly advised that you visit the shop first and try them on.

Moreover, this is strongly recommended than buying online as looking for the right fit can prove to be quite a challenge especially when you’re not familiar with the brand’s sizing.

  • The Leather Material

Leather-made steel toe shoes are made to last. They are not only durable but can also be used in virtually any type of weather while providing a waterproof or water-resistant feature.

By all means, steer clear of steel toe shoes that are made of canvas or fake leather as these may not withstand the wear and tear of your job.

Your Quick Buying Guide To Choosing The Best And Most Comfortable Steel Toe Shoes

As we have now revealed the features you should be looking into when buying a pair of steel toe shoes, it’s about time to unveil a few yet significant things to consider when looking for one in the market.

  • The Correct Shoe Size

The last thing you want to have is a pair of safety shoes with an incorrect shoe size. This type of product is bound to vary in terms of sizes, so it is always best to check them on a website first (whether their variants run big, small, wide, or narrow.

Even more so, try to inquire whether these shops have physical stores in which you can try these shoes on.

  • The Insoles

As we have just mentioned previously, removable insoles are an indicator that you can alter the level of comfort and support from a steel toe shoe. These insoles are beneficial for those users who intend to spend long hours with their shoes.

  • The Honest Reviews

One of the best ways to know whether a pair of safety shoes suit your needs or not is by reading its reviews online. Whenever a product has generated an enormous amount of negative reviews, chances are you’re heading for a mess of an experience.

Either way, look for comments that emphasize on comfort and durability, and if they are peaking, you’re in luck!

Best And Most Comfortable Steel Toe Shoes In 2020

**Below, you'll find more detailed reviews, but you can also click links above to check current prices and read customer's reviews on Amazon.

1. KEEN Utility Men’s Flint Low Steel Toe Work Shoe

Best Steel Toe Shoes

On our fourth contender, it is now clear that the competition is getting tighter. The KEEN Utility Men’s Flint Low Steel Toe Work Shoe is adamant on not getting any reliable and key features unturned with its competitive offerings.

From its asymmetrical toe protection that is specially made to fit both of your feet, its molded reinforcement right on its toe box, down to its metatomical footbed mechanism, this one is definitely not slowing down.

The Flint Low from KEEN also features a fusion of durability and protection, giving you an unmistakably high-performing outdoor shoe. It is ideal for those who travel on their daily work and those who frequent their job sites.

On the other hand, the shoes can also be work whenever you’re hiking the mountains or even just taking a stroll by the beach.


  • Ideal for travelers, job sites, and mountains
  • Features asymmetrical toe protection for a better fit
  • Comes with molded reinforcement on the toe box against abrasion, mild impact
  • Equipped with its proprietary “internal support mechanism”
  • Also suitable for carpenters and contractors


  • Has thinner sole inserts
  • Sole is a bit fragile for some

2. New Balance Men’s MID627 Steel-Toe Work Shoe

Best Steel Toe Shoes

If you’re a bona fide athlete or a self-proclaimed one and looking for a pair of steel-toe work shoes with just the right fit, then this New Balance’s entry might very well be suited to your needs.

The brand is adamant that their products are not made to fit an image but rather are designed to fit. Whatever the case, you’ll have an assurance that you’d only get the finest shoes from this company.

The steel-toe work shoes from New Balance features the proprietary ABZORB cushioning and the much-needed Static Dissipative Construction. Also, the shoes’ outsoles are slip-resistant which should also make them ideal if you’re working on a site.


  • Features ABZORB cushioning for superior comfort
  • Comes with Static Dissipative Construction
  • Ideal for athletes
  • Slip-resistant
  • Suitable for additional insoles


  • Steel toe may be a bit undersized
  • Soles may be a little fragile

3. Timberland Pro Men’s 40008 Mudsill Low Steel-Toe Lace-Up

Best Steel Toe Shoes


Timberland’s PRO Mudsill is a testament as to why this brand is still leading the pack. With all the features that you’d expect from a classic Timberland PRO work shoe, this first contender is determined to go beyond that. It is made with premium materials that only offer the best in terms of durability and comfort.

Your protection is also of paramount priority with its steel safety features and the abrasion-resistant synthetic toes. Meanwhile, the pair also features an electrical hazard protection.

On the other hand, your comfort shouldn’t be compromised as the shoes are equipped with some of the most relevant features in this segment. They include a mesh lining that comes with an antimicrobial treatment that should veer away those unwanted odors, making your feet all the more comfortable.


  • Steel safety toe
  • Electrical hazard protection
  • Mesh lining with antimicrobial treatment for comfort and odor control
  • Secure fit 
  • Structural support due to its nylon shank 
  • Features cement construction for flexibility; reduction for break-in time


  • Hooks for the laces at the top are not made of metal
  • Included soles may be uncomfortable for some

4. KEEN Utility Men’s Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe

Best Steel Toe Shoes


There is no stopping for KEEN in its second and our last entry in this list. Perhaps its most hallmark offering comes with its distinct comfort.

Apart from its airflow that definitely goes a long way for users who are on their feet extensively, the pair also boasts of a mesh liner that gives breathability right within the confines of this footwear, keeping your feet cool and comfy during the warmest of situations.

Meanwhile, Atlanta Cool also has a dual density compression molded EVA in its midsole; a removable metatomical dual density EVA footbed is likewise included.

Moreover, its left and right portions are equipped with asymmetrical steel shoes, giving you that ultimate protection whenever you’re in a job site or working with heavy things.


  • Leather and mesh materials
  • Features left and right asymmetrical steel toes
  • Rubber outsole comes with non-marking, oil- and slip-resistant offering
  • Mesh liner for provision on breathability
  • Lightweight


  • May not be ideal for walking or in a warehouse environment
  • Produces loud, squeaking sound

5. Skechers for Work Men’s Soft Stride Steel Toe Work Shoe

Best Steel Toe Shoes

A smooth, suave, and sheer amount of workmanship is evident in this lone contender from Skechers. The Work Men’s Soft Stride Steel Toe Work Shoe is reliable, relative to its four main perks that comes with it: a composite safety toe, a lightweight safety toe, the slip-resistant feature, and the steel safety toe.

All of which specifically provides their respective benefits, ultimately giving you an experience that is both durable and comforting.

Soft Stride is also especially ideal for those who commute regularly or the ones who dedicate half of their daily lives standing either on their work or just a leisure.

The product is expertly crafted, fusing leather and synthetic materials which feature a full ghillie lace-up panel along with a padded tongue, a collar, and a pull tab right at your heel.


  • Slip-resistant outsoles
  • Ultra lightweight toe; high-grade, durable materials for strength
  • Can withstand impact and compression
  • Ideal for commuters
  • Rubber sole


  • Not so well-stitched
  • Soles are a bit fragile


Overall, it’s been quite a tight race among our entries. This just points strictly that a lot of products out there are not only durable but are quality enough to warrant these well-deserved scores.

The KEEN Utility Men’s Flint Low Steel Toe Work Shoe eclipses them slightly yet significantly in terms of its consistent provision of comfort and durability with its long list of included technologies and features.

From its modern and stylish look right to its breathable mechanism, KEEN is evidently not taking any valuable perks unturned.

Was the article helpful enough to let you finally decide on your purchase? Do you think another product deserves a spot on our list? If you think so, please feel free to sound them off in the comment section below.

Emily Brathen

Hi there! I'm Emily Brathen. I am a fitness and yoga instructor and a mom of one. Despite my hectic schedule, I still find time for doing the thing I love most - fitness and yoga. I love doing and teaching fitness and yoga because in my own little way, I am able to encourage people to take health and fitness back into their own hands.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments